⇦ BACK

Nolan Listens to Constituents on Mining

Reader’s View: Nolan Listens to Constituents on Mining

Duluth News Tribune (Daily)

Daniel Kingsley

May 13, 2015

 

Congressman Rick Nolan has come under fire for supporting future copper/nickel and iron mining operations in Northeastern Minnesota. Various groups and individuals have even gone as far as questioning his loyalty to his constituents and his fitness to serve.

 

Hard-working, middle-class families of the 8th Congressional District support Nolan’s views on mining. The entire legislative delegation that represents the Iron Range supports Nolan’s views on mining. Furthermore, both Minnesota U.S. senators, Al Franken and Amy Klobuchar, support Nolan’s views on mining.

 

Right now hundreds of people are losing their jobs on the Iron Range. Plants and mines are closing, and we are entering another contraction.

 

Our region will continue to lose young families that will move in search of greater prosperity and new opportunities if the proposal that St. Paul Congresswoman Betty McCollum is pushing becomes law.

 

Opponents of mining like to paint the picture that you can’t have new mines and a safe environment. They use scare tactics and fear-based hypotheticals to drive a wedge between environmentalists and working people.

 

I am proud Rep. Nolan trusts the laws, regulations and processes of our state and federal agencies and believes you can safely mine and protect the environment at the same time.

 

Nolan knows who he represents. He represents all the people who live in Northeastern Minnesota, not just a vocal minority of well-financed opponents of industry — and not just people who come up here from the metro for vacation.

 

Congresswoman McCollum would do well to focus her attention on the substantial problems that exist in her own district. U.S. Rep. Rick Nolan has us all covered up here.

 

Mining Lessons for Merit Badges

When Geologist Frank Pezzutto asked the dozen or so Boy Scouts what gypsum crystals are used for in our everyday life, all but one stood there in Minnesota Discovery Center’s Hall of Geology baffled.

“Sheet rock,” yelled one of the scouts.

And he was right.

That was just one of the many tidbits of information the 50-plus scouts learned while attending the Mining in Society Merit Badge-Spring Camporee earlier this month. The first-of-its-kind event was organized and sponsored by the Minnesota Section of the Society of Mining, Metallurgy & Exploration (SME).

Roughly eight troops of the Boundary Waters District of the Voyageurs Area Council Boy Scouts of America participated. The scouts were receptive and enjoyed the day, said Bill Beyer, district chair.

“The boys were really excited, and learned a lot about mining that they didn’t already know in terms of growing up here on the Iron Range,” he said. “They got a better picture of how mining happens and how big a part of our economy it is.”

The scouts spent the day at the Minnesota Museum of Mining, Minnesota Discovery Center (MDC) and a local mine fulfilling the requirements of the Mining Merit Badge. The camporee concluded with an awards ceremony, during which the scouts each received his badge.

To earn the badge, the scouts were required to do several things, including learn about minerals, use a map to locate five mining enterprises, identify potential hazards a miner may encounter, discuss the dangers someone might encounter at an abandoned mine, visit a mining/minerals museum or an active mine, find out what is being done to help control environmental impacts, read about reclamation, meet with a worker in the mining industry and/or research three career opportunities in the mining industry, among other options.

The badge is about a year old, according to Beyer. He said it was devised by a joint effort of Boy Scouts of America and SME.

“We really had both sides of the aisle involved with this, and both were really excited to do this,” he added, noting that not many scouts have earned this merit badge yet. “ … We felt this was a fitting badge for the boys to earn because of being from the Iron Range.”

Beyer also pointed out that merit badges span a range of topics, some of which may spark interest in a scout as potential long-terms goals or even future career options — including mining.

Corie Ekholm, chair of the Northern Subsection of SME, said the camporee went off as planned.

“All has been good,” she said mid-way through the day. “We have beautiful weather, the boys seem very engaged and are learning a lot.”

This was SME’s first time hosting such an event. The goal was to offer an eight-hour, hands-on experience that would result in each participant earning a full badge.

“They really are learning about many aspects of mining — from safety to what the minerals produce after they are mined, to how they are recycled in the afterlife and what really happened in our mining operations,” said Ekholm.

She also noted that SME and Boy Scouts were grateful to the Minnesota Museum of Mining, (MDC) and the local mine for allowing them to utilize their properties.

And if the scouts take just one thing from the day?

“Just how important mining is and how much it plays a role in our everyday lives,” said Ekholm. “Everything we use, most of it comes from something that was mined.”

But that’s not the only main message they took with them

“The biggest thing that seemed to stick with them is how big the mining process is — from turning rock into a product,” said Beyer. “They got a better picture of mining as a whole.”

Reject False Choice Between Jobs and Environment

Mining Is Our Livelihood

Copper-Nickel Mining Vital to Region’s Economy

Reader’s View: Copper-Nickel Mining Vital to Region’s Economy

Duluth News Tribune (Daily)

Arik Forsman

May 8, 2015

The city of Duluth and surrounding communities have made progress toward a more stable economic atmosphere since my wife and I moved here nearly 10 years ago for college, but unemployment in our region is still higher than in some other areas. The layoff numbers keep increasing on the Iron Range, where my father, uncle and cousin are waiting to hear what’s happening next at the taconite mines where they work.

Fortunately, copper-nickel mining projects in the Duluth Complex, one of the world’s largest untapped sources of copper, nickel and other strategic metals, will supply hundreds of mining and spin-off jobs to the region.

With good-paying, long-term copper-nickel mining jobs in Minnesota, more northern Minnesota residents will be able to stay and raise families in our communities, and businesses statewide will benefit from purchasing goods and services associated with a thriving copper-nickel mining industry.

Taxes and royalties from copper-nickel mining projects will benefit local governments and schools districts across the state. These mining projects are the catalyst to long-term benefits to this area, an area that celebrates the tourism industry but cannot rely on it to sustain our region.

Minerals from mining projects are key components of technology we use every day and are critical to the clean-energy movement. Wind turbines and solar panels are just a few important products made from these metals. As Minnesota seeks to be a leader in clean energy, so, too, should our state policymakers support our ability to responsibly mine the essential minerals that supply this industry with raw material.

Mining companies are taking steps to ensure these essential elements will be mined responsibly. Support for copper-nickel mining is support for long-term economic stability, good-paying jobs, and clean energy for our state. It is an opportunity too great for us to pass up.

PolyMet Will Add Much-Needed Diversity to Iron Range

Cherry: PolyMet Will Add Much-Needed Diversity to Iron Range

BusinessNorth (Monthly)

Editorial Board

May 7, 2015

Both the copper market and PolyMet are positioned well for future growth, the company’s president and CEO said April 15 at the annual Society of Mining Engineers Minnesota Conference in Duluth.

Jon Cherry said a company that mines copper, nickel and other precious metals will diversify the state’s mining industry at a time when the iron ore market is struggling with low commodity prices, which have triggered layoffs.

“The iron price, as I’m sure you are painfully aware, continues to drop. There are a lot of forecasts of iron falling to $40 a ton and some suggest it could fall to the $30 range, which is pretty brutal. Who can tell if there’s any end in sight,” said Cherry, who is leading PolyMet through the final phases of environmental review, financing and development of its top-tier mineral deposits near Hoyt Lakes.

The demand for precious metals is being fueled by rapid development in countries emerging from the third world.

“In China, you literally have a billion people moving from a subsistence lifestyle to a middle class lifestyle, and they want all the products we take for granted – electricity, indoor plumbing and cell phones,” Cherry said, noting that the same is happening in Brazil and India. “It all takes a lot of natural resources – a lot of copper.”

During 2014, 24 million tons of copper were consumed worldwide, with China using 45 percent of it. Demand for the metal, which is needed in electrical and electronic applications, has increased in 28 of the past 30 years, he said.

Further fueling demand are clean energy applications such as windmills, which typically need 10,000 pounds of copper, and hybrid motor vehicles, which need twice as much copper as standard cars and trucks. In terms of generating electricity, solar panels need twice as much copper per watt as windmills, Cherry noted.

“Over the next several years, we believe the market will be in balance for copper, and prices will be stable or rising,” he said.

If developed, the PolyMet and NorthMet mines and processing facilities will generate $515 million per year, according to a University of Minnesota Duluth study. The company will directly support 350 full time jobs with two spinoff positions likely to be created for each of them. Similar developments will generate a similar number of positions.

Environmentalists have strongly opposed the establishment of facilities that mine minerals that contain sulfide, contending there is no suitable way to permanently prevent the release of sulfuric acid into the water supply. PolyMet has addressed that issue through its Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) and Supplemental Draft EIS.

As the project approaches fruition, Cherry warned that environmentalists will likely increase political pressure to stop it.

“There will be a higher noise level” in the traditional press and social media, he said. “Don’t get overly excited about that.”

Range Mayors Stand with Nolan on Mining

Reader’s View: Range Mayors Stand with Nolan on Mining

Duluth News Tribune (Daily)

Chuck Novak

April 26, 2015

This letter is in response to recent claims posited by a vocal minority about the future of mining in Northeastern Minnesota. As Iron Range mayors and township board chairmen, we represent the interests of Northeastern Minnesotans. We’re tired of people who represent the interests of St. Paul or other areas of the state pretending to know what is best for our region. We live and work in Northeastern Minnesota and take great pride in representing and preserving our Iron Range heritage. It is our responsibility to carry our respective communities into the future, to build on past successes and create opportunities for our children to thrive — and we do this unapologetically.

Rep. Betty McCollum, who recently introduced legislation designed to halt mining in Northeastern Minnesota, appears to have forgotten what district she represents. It’s St. Paul and its surrounding suburbs, not Northeastern Minnesota. Anti-mining activist Becky Rom, who made her home and living in the Twin Cities for decades and now comes back to enjoy our wilderness in her retirement, also doesn’t represent our collective communities’ interests.

U.S. Rep. Rick Nolan, on the other hand, is doing exactly what he was elected to do: listen to us and represent our way of life. He recognizes the need to diversify our economy and embrace new mining opportunities that will preserve our rich heritage — when it can be done responsibly. We applaud his steadfastness and leadership. We appreciate his focus on issues that are important to his district.

We trust the process, and we trust the strong rules and regulations Minnesota has in place to ensure protection of the environment. And we trust Rep. Nolan to continue representing our interests.

The writer is mayor of Ely.

This letter also was signed by and is from Aurora Mayor Mary Hess, Babbitt Mayor Andrea Zupancich, Biwabik Mayor Jim Weikum, Chisholm Mayor Mike A. Jugovich, Embarrass Township Board Chairman Gene Wright, Eveleth Mayor Bob Vlaisavljevich, Gilbert Mayor Rob Kutsi, Grand Rapids Mayor Dale Adams, Hibbing Mayor Rick Cannata, Hoyt Lakes Mayor Mark Skelton, Keewatin Mayor William King, Mountain Iron Mayor Gary Skalko, Nashwauk Mayor Ben DeNucci, Tower Mayor Joshua Carlson, Virginia Mayor Larry Cuffe, and White Township Board Chairman Edward Kippely.

Local Legislators Blast Anti-Mining Bill

Local Legislators Blast Anti-Mining Bill

Hibbing Daily Tribune (Daily)

Bill Hanna

April 18, 2015 

Fourth District U.S. Rep. Betty McCollum is getting plenty of pushback on her anti-mining bill from fellow Minnesota Democratic Party members of Congress.

McCollum’s National Park and Wilderness Waters Protection Act would take away lands in the Rainy River Basin from the federal mining leasing program and would also put conditions where current mineral leases exist.

Her measure is clearly aimed at the Twin Metals copper/nickel/precious metals project near Ely and Babbitt.

But Twin Metals Minnesota officials are seeking environmental protections that are already in place.

Eighth District U.S. Rep. Rick Nolan and Sens. Amy Klobuchar and Al Franken see the issue the same way.

“We already have strong state and federal standards in place to protect our precious resources,” said Sen. Franken on Thursday in response to a Mesabi Daily News request for comment on the issue.

“By adhering to these standards, we can develop our resources in a responsible way while also protecting the environment. I don’t believe we need new legislation to preempt the process that we have in place,” he said.

Sen. Klobuchar said in her email response, “Mining projects are already required to undergo a thorough, site-specific environmental evaluation, and this legislation would not only create unnecessary duplication at taxpayer expense but also threaten the economic future of the Iron Range.”

Rep. Nolan was even stronger in comments released Wednesday evening, calling the McCollum proposal a “regulatory scheme.”

“I will vigorously oppose Congresswoman Betty McCollum’s new proposal to ban mining projects in northeastern Minnesota. The simple truth is, this bill is a duplicative, overlapping regulatory scheme designed to prohibit mining on the Iron Range.

“The fact is, we have the brains, technology and regulations to both mine and protect the environment. The permitting and environmental review process required for new mining projects is already thorough, rigorous and effective in protecting the environment and the public interest. It can take years — even decades to complete,” the congressman said.

Nolan praised the nonferrous mineral initiatives on the Iron Range.

“Mining is what we do on the Range and is at the heart of our regional and national economy. This is truly a “Made in America” industry — with 140 prosperous years of quality products and thousands of good-paying jobs.

“Moreover, mining and precious metals are the foundation of all our modern technologies — transportation, communications, health, environment and advancements in energy-saving vehicles, solar and wind energy that reduce our carbon footprint,” he said.

Nolan also referred to his personal history in Congress, which includes being there when both the Voyageurs National Park and Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness were created.

“…. I was in Congress when the BWCA and Voyageurs National Park were established. The agreement at that time was clear — both written and unwritten. More than a million acres of federal lands were set aside for national parks and wilderness areas. In exchange, the remaining federal lands would be reserved for multiple use purpose outside those boundaries, including forestry and mining. That was the agreement. It was heralded as a good deal then, and we are duty-bound to honor it now.

“I am reasonably confident we can defeat this newly proposed regulation and legislation that would prohibit mining on the Range,” the congressman concluded.

Nolan Leading on Jobs and Environment

Reader’s View: Nolan Leading on Jobs and the Environment

Duluth News Tribune (Daily)

Craig Olson

April 16, 2015

 

Reading the News Tribune’s April 7 editorial (Our View: “No apologies from Nolan on environment”) reminded me that Congressman Rick Nolan always has stated that we do not need to choose between jobs or the environment. This is a false choice, and Nolan’s leadership demonstrates his understanding of the complex issues we face.

 

He understands that there is a need for and wide use of oil, iron ore, copper and other metals, and he pursues the most responsible way to meet this public need. Without his leadership, and without raising the level of dialogue about these issues, we would be left two unrealistic choices: get these products from countries that have harmful or nonexistent environmental and worker regulations or go back to a time before refrigerators, phones, transportation, wind turbines, modern homes and countless other products.

 

Nolan operates in reality and seeks out solutions that have the best environmental and worker protections along the way.

 

No Apologies from Nolan on Environment